Are Mods Designed for PC MelonLoader Always Compatible with LemonLoader on Android? Why or Why Not?

by

If you’re diving into Unity game modding on Android using LemonLoader, one key question comes up often: Can PC MelonLoader mods just work on LemonLoader? The short answer: No, not always.

While LemonLoader’s main goal is to bring MelonLoader’s powerful modding capabilities to Android, there are significant differences under the hood that often prevent PC mods from working seamlessly on Android.

Why Mods for PC MelonLoader Often Aren’t Compatible with LemonLoader:

1️⃣ Fundamental Architectural and OS Differences

  • 🖥️ Processor architecture (x86/x64 vs. ARM):
    PC mods target x86 or x64 CPUs, while Android devices—including standalone VR headsets like Meta Quest—run on ARM processors. Binary code built for one architecture simply won’t run on the other. Although recompiling is sometimes possible, many mods rely on platform-specific native code that won’t translate easily.
  • 🛠️ Operating system APIs and libraries:
    Windows and Android are very different. Mods often depend on Windows-specific system APIs (like Win32, DirectX, or file system behavior) that don’t exist or behave differently on Android. LemonLoader adapts MelonLoader to Android, but it can’t automatically convert all Windows-specific calls to Android equivalents.
  • 🔐 File system and permissions:
    Android’s sandboxing and strict file permissions (especially with Scoped Storage on newer Android versions) mean mods expecting broad file access might fail. Paths, access methods, and file handling differ greatly from PCs.

2️⃣ Unity Scripting Backend Differences (Mono vs. IL2CPP)

  • ⚙️ Many older PC Unity games use Mono, which is easier to mod since it allows runtime injection via Just-In-Time (JIT) compilation.
  • 🚀 Modern Android Unity games, especially VR/mobile ones, often use IL2CPP—a highly optimized compilation of C# into C++—making runtime injection much tougher.
  • 🧩 Although LemonLoader supports IL2CPP, mods built for Mono-based PC games might not function properly if the Android game uses IL2CPP, even if the mod is pure C#.

3️⃣ Native Code and Platform-Specific Dependencies

  • 💻 Many PC mods include native C++ libraries (.dll files) or depend on hardware/drivers exclusive to Windows. These are incompatible with Android’s environment.
  • 🔄 Even mods that appear purely C# might rely on .NET Framework or Core libraries unavailable or limited in Android’s runtime environment.

4️⃣ UI and Input Differences

  • 🖱️ Mods that add new UI elements or use keyboard/mouse controls may not translate well to Android’s touch or VR controller inputs.
  • ❌ Without significant UI/input adjustments, the user experience might be broken or unusable.

5️⃣ Game Version and API Differences

  • 🎮 A mod made for a specific PC game version may rely on code or APIs that differ in the Android version, due to platform-specific optimizations or changes.
  • ✅ Conversely, some mods are crafted specifically for Android versions, considering these unique differences.

When Might Mods Be Compatible or Adaptable?

  • 🔧 Pure C# mods using Unity’s public APIs: These have a better chance of working, especially if the Android game uses a compatible Unity version and scripting backend.
  • 📂 Simple data or config mods: Mods that just load textures, sounds, or configuration files without deep code injection tend to be more portable, assuming file paths and loading mechanisms are compatible.
  • 📱 Mods designed specifically for LemonLoader and Android: These are naturally compatible, often developed within dedicated Android modding communities.

In Conclusion:

While LemonLoader is the essential bridge to bring MelonLoader’s power to Android, it does not guarantee that PC MelonLoader mods will work out of the box. Differences in processor architecture, OS, security, Unity scripting backends, and game versions mean many PC mods need significant work to be ported.

Always assume PC mods are incompatible with LemonLoader unless the mod developer or community explicitly confirms compatibility or porting.

For the best experience, rely on mods made or verified for LemonLoader and Android.

Want to learn more or get involved?

Leave a Comment